Jeber Photo Clubs

Discussion on: Image 135 - "Bee and Clover"

Discussion, revisions and constructive criticisms of Image 135 - "Bee and Clover"

Original - Camille (cnut)
full image

CameraKonica Minolta » Dimage Z3
Original Date2004-09-14 04:48:03
Focal Length10.2767944336 mm
Aperturef 3.2
ISO973144114
Exposure Time1/80 sec
FlashUnknown: 2
TripodNo
[Full Exif]
Photographers Note:
none
Adrian Warren (AdrianW)
Msg: #1


June 19th 2005
19:35:15
Nice shot! You've captured this one well. Two things I'd think about changing if this were my shot, firstly there's a bit of noise in the background - that's fairly easy to squash using something like NeatImage, secondly I find the two blades of grass sticking up at the bottom of the frame marginally distracting - it's a bit late to recompose the shot to avoid them, so consider cloning them out instead.

I've created a Workshop for you - I hope you don't mind. First I loaded it into NeatImage, and used the bottom right hand corner to create a noise profile - and then used it to filter the image. Next I loaded that as a New Layer into Photoshop, on top of the original. Then I used a soft-edged eraser to knock out the areas that didn't need noise reduction - i.e. the insect itself. Then I applied a little UnSharp Mask to the image to bring out some more detail - 35%, 9.8px to enhance contrast, and 95%, 0.8px to enhance fine detail.

Then I used a soft edged clone tool to remove the two blades of grass, working along the direction of any features in the background.

I hope you like it :)

Revision: 1
Adrian Warren (AdrianW)
Camille (cnut)
Msg: #2


June 19th 2005
22:12:04
I like what you did to Mr Wood Bee.  Thanks so much.  Well in my few days here I have learned one thing I need to do more post processing.  I do need to find my personal parameters as to what to do and when to stop.  I have this fear of over doing it.  Time to let go and free the mind, hmmm...      
Andy Leach (RedAndy)
Msg: #3


June 21st 2005
06:43:52
Wow. That has to be the _best_ cloning job I have ever seen, I can't believe you created a section of bee wing so seamless. Utterly flabbergasting and awe inspiring.
Ali Watters (Ali)
Msg: #4


June 21st 2005
07:27:36
I'm enjoying the bee shots as well - nice to get up close and personal with these industrious insects. I don't know if it's possible to bring out some detail in the clover top left.

>_best_ cloning job

I was going to say that too! - great job :)
Bob Wallace (BobTrips)
Msg: #5


June 21st 2005
12:50:24
I downloaded the OP and ran the Burn Brush over the whitest areas of the clover.  There's a bit of detail lurking there.  Some careful work (Adrian?) should bring it out.
Adrian Warren (AdrianW)
Msg: #6


July 9th 2005
14:35:45
Glad you all liked it :)

The key to successful cloning is to think about where the lines of the image are, and then try and find areas of the image you can pick a similar structure from. When you're out of available structures, use the eyedropper to grab a suitable colour and then use the pencil tool to draw it in...

In case you're curious, I use a mouse for retouch - I do have a Wacom A4, but I find it too big and cumbersome to use. If I were buying again I'd get the A5 - although the Cintiq is awesome, if you've just robbed a bank ;)
Number Users: 5
Number of Posts: 6
To Reply Join Jeber Photo Clubs - you will be required to join this club
Versions

Revision: 1
Adrian Warren (AdrianW)